[
  {
    "id": "20261010-103156-c4ed73e",
    "runId": "20261010-095814",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 6.07,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 83,
      "notes": "The front page is a true data grid with a visible th header row, thin cell borders, right-aligned numeric columns for score and comments, and only the lead row highlighted in yellow, which matches the brief closely. At 375px the table keeps all columns but squeezes them, so the age and comments columns are clipped off the right edge and the title column wraps heavily, which hurts scannability. Numbers are not clearly monospace or tabular-figure styled, and the thread page reuses the table header well but leaves a large empty area below the comments.",
      "adherence": 88,
      "novelty": 85,
      "craft": 74
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 0,
    "costUsd": 0.0608,
    "previousRelease": "20261010-002557-56bd5f6",
    "diffStat": "+262 -241",
    "candidate": 4,
    "brief": "spreadsheet",
    "briefOk": true,
    "domChanged": true,
    "createdAt": 1791628316
  },
  {
    "id": "20261010-002557-56bd5f6",
    "runId": "20261010-000025",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 5.53,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 52,
      "notes": "The pastel soft-card direction is clearly realized: rounded pastel cards with gentle shadows and dark text on the front page, and a soft card header on the thread page. However, the brief asks for pill-shaped tags for domain and comment count, and the comment count and domain do appear as pills, which is good, but the card layout is a single vertical stack rather than a distinctly soft-UI app surface, and avatar-like spacing is not evident. Novelty is limited because the page is still a single-column list of the same story rows as the live site, only restacked and recolored. At 375px the layout reflows cleanly with no overflow, though the metadata wraps awkwardly and the nav pills wrap onto two rows.",
      "adherence": 62,
      "novelty": 30,
      "craft": 60
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 2,
    "costUsd": 0.1576,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-235900-437def3",
    "diffStat": "+166 -208",
    "candidate": 0,
    "brief": "pastel soft UI",
    "briefOk": true,
    "domChanged": true,
    "createdAt": 1791591957
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-235900-437def3",
    "runId": "20261009-234422",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 6.46,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 72,
      "notes": "The front page follows the pastel soft UI brief well: rounded pastel cards with gentle shadows, dark text, and pill-shaped score and comment tags on a three-column masonry grid. The brief's required structure is only partly visible, since the domain sits in a small monospace tag but the comment count is a pill rather than clearly inside a small element, and the thread page's comment nesting is shown only by indentation. At 375px the cards stack cleanly, though the nav pill wraps awkwardly and some comment pills break onto their own lines. Ranking is weaker than it could be because the cards have very uneven heights and large empty bottom areas.",
      "adherence": 78,
      "novelty": 74,
      "craft": 62
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 1,
    "costUsd": 0.0421,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-153451-10b7ae6",
    "diffStat": "+270 -89",
    "candidate": 1,
    "brief": "pastel soft UI",
    "briefOk": true,
    "domChanged": true,
    "createdAt": 1791590340
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-153451-10b7ae6",
    "runId": "20261009-151930",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 8.51,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 72,
      "notes": "The front page has a clear hierarchy: a large lead story, bold serif titles, then small-caps metadata, and a tidy two-column grid with consistent rules between entries. The palette is restrained cream with dark green and rust accents, which feels intentional and still reads as a news page. The 375px view stacks cleanly but metadata wraps awkwardly (points and comments split onto a second line) and the lead title is heavy. On the thread page, the green left bars and progressive indentation make nesting depth legible, though the nested indents shrink the measure quickly and deep replies look crowded toward the right edge."
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 0,
    "costUsd": 0.0111,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-134625-6643a1d",
    "diffStat": "+8 -8",
    "candidate": 1,
    "brief": "newspaper broadsheet: serif masthead, columns, hairline rules, small caps for metadata",
    "domChanged": true,
    "createdAt": 1791560091
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-134625-6643a1d",
    "runId": "20261009-133916",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 8.51,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 72,
      "notes": "The front page at 1280px has a clear title-over-metadata hierarchy with bold serif titles, small-caps metadata, and a restrained cream palette that reads as a news page. The two-column layout keeps 30 stories skimmable, with rank numbers hanging in the margin and a thin vertical rule separating columns. At 375px the single column holds up, though metadata wraps awkwardly (words like 'com-ments' and 'com-' break across lines) and the header nav wraps messily. The thread page uses green left borders and indentation to show nesting, which works, but the italic body text at this size is somewhat tiring to read over long comments."
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 1,
    "costUsd": 0.0308,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-105817-d1c2f42",
    "diffStat": "+23 -24",
    "candidate": 1,
    "domChanged": true,
    "createdAt": 1791553585
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-105817-d1c2f42",
    "runId": "20261009-104231",
    "specVersion": 2,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 8.51,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 74,
      "notes": "The front page has a distinct warm-paper, serif editorial look with small-caps metadata that stays quieter than the bold titles, and the two-column 30-story grid at 1280px is easy to skim with numbers aligned in a consistent gutter. The lead story is given appropriate prominence without competing too hard with the rest. The thread page uses nested left rules in green and grey that make comment depth visible, though the deepest replies get squeezed toward the right edge and the italic body text in long comments is a bit tiring to read. Overall it is restrained and coherent, with some hierarchy weakness in the thread view and a large unused area below the footer on the front page."
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 0,
    "costUsd": 0.0177,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-003724-49aa276",
    "diffStat": "+28 -188",
    "candidate": 9,
    "createdAt": 1791543497
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-003724-49aa276",
    "runId": "20261009-003214",
    "specVersion": 1,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 8.51,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 68,
      "notes": "The front page uses a warm cream background with a serif face, bold titles, and small-caps metadata that stays visibly quieter than titles, giving a distinct newspaper-like point of view. Two columns with a rule divider and numbered entries make 30 stories skimmable at 1280px, though the page ends at about 1300px leaving a large empty area below. At 375px the single column works but metadata wraps awkwardly ('com-ments' breaks, orphaned words), and the nav wraps onto a second line. The thread page has clear nesting via left rules and indentation, but the depth lines are faint and the body text is long-measure at full width, reducing comfort."
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 0,
    "costUsd": 0.0137,
    "previousRelease": "20261009-002709-a9a323f",
    "diffStat": "+136 -88",
    "candidate": 1,
    "createdAt": 1791506244
  },
  {
    "id": "20261009-002709-a9a323f",
    "runId": "20261009-002502",
    "specVersion": 1,
    "tier1": {
      "lakeBuild": "ok",
      "axioms": [
        "propext",
        "Classical.choice",
        "Quot.sound"
      ],
      "selftest": "ok"
    },
    "tier2": {
      "vnu": 0,
      "axe": 0,
      "contrastMin": 6.8,
      "reflowWidth": 375,
      "csp": "ok"
    },
    "judge": {
      "score": 62,
      "notes": "The front page is dense and very compact, with monospace type that reads clearly, but the line height is tight and the metadata sits inline with titles so it competes with them; wrapped meta lines break awkwardly (e.g. 'comments' orphaned on the next line). The thread page shows nesting via indented left rules, which makes depth visible, though the comment text is a long undifferentiated column with little spacing between comments. Palette is restrained cream and brown with a single accent, which feels intentional and news-like. The 375px front page reflows acceptably but gets long and cramped, with metadata wrapping into ragged lines."
    },
    "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
    "repairRounds": 0,
    "costUsd": 0.0169,
    "previousRelease": null,
    "diffStat": "+78 -78",
    "candidate": 0,
    "createdAt": 1791505629
  }
]